Home > Lawsuit    
OneSimpleLoan Loses Lawsuit in U.S. Supreme Court, Yet Notes Victory as Catalyst for 'Single Holder Rule' Repeal





On February 19, 2008, the United States Supreme Court ruled that it would not consider OneSimpleLoan's lawsuit against the Department of Education over the company's request for a temporary injunction of a ruling that disallows the two-step student loan consolidation process after March 31, 2006, rather than after June 30, 2006, when other student loan-related provisions of the recently-signed Deficit Reduction Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 2005 take effect.

Our lawsuit had also challenged the constitutionality of the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 (DRA). This legislation incorporated changes to many Federal government programs including the Higher Education Act, which contained the actual student loan consolidation changes we are fighting.

The initial lawsuit was filed on April 18, 2006. Although the consolidation portion of our case was dismissed, our lawsuit was a victorious catalyst behind the June 15, 2006 repeal of the "single lender rule." This repeal was approved as part of the Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act (i.e., H.R. 4939). This repeal means that student loan borrowers can now consolidate their student loans through a variety of student lenders and will no longer be tied to their original lender. This allows borrowers to 'shop around' to take full advantage of the consolidation offers with the most favorable terms regardless of lender.

"Although we lost the case in the U.S. Supreme Court, we are proud that we were able to help make a difference in the lives of student loan borrowers and their families," notes OneSimpleLoan President and CEO Paul J. Simino. "We will continue to be a strong advocate to help students obtain and manage their student loans before during and after college."

View the details and press coverage about this lawsuit by clicking on the following articles:

US Supreme Court Ruling on OneSimpleLoan Lawsuit vs. Secretary of the Department of Education   U.S. Supreme Court Ruling OneSimpleLoan, et al. v. U.S. Secretary of Education, et al. (February 19, 2008)
 
OneSimpleLoan Lawsuit vs. Secretary of the Department of Education   Actual Lawsuit Filing Document OneSimpleLoan, et al. v. U.S. Secretary of Education, et al., 2006 Civ. 2979 (S.D.N.Y., filed Apr. 18, 2006)
 
OneSompleLoan Lawsuit Press Release   Official OneSimpleLoan Press Release about the Filing
 
Senator Kennedy Endorses Student Loan Consolidation   Senator Edward Kennedy Encourages Students to Consolidate their Student Loans
 
OneSimpleLoan vs. U.S. Secretary of Education Lawsuit Documents   Additional Lawsuit Filings OneSimpleLoan, et al. v. U.S. Secretary of Education
 
Paul Simino Interview with HEWI   Paul Simino Interview with Higher Education Washington Inc (HEWI)
 

Congressional Letter about Student Loan Consolidation

  Letter to Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings about Limiting Consolidation Options
 

House Democrats Encourage Consolidation Prior to July 1

  House Democrats Urge Students and Parents to Consolidate Federal College Loans by July 1
 

Senator Hillary Clinton Proposes Student Borrower Bill of Rights Act

  Senator Hillary Clinton Calls For Student Borrower Bill Of Rights
 

OneSimpleLoan interview in St. Petersburg Times

  Oldsmar Man Leads Student Loan Fight (St. Petersburg Times, 6/7/2006)
 

Consolidator Will Fight Student Loan Rule - Tampa Tribune

  Consolidator Will Fight Student Loan Rule (Tampa Tribune, 6/15/2006)
 

Consolidation could save on college loan  - BayNews9

  Consolidation Could Save on College Loan (BayNews9, 6/26/2006)
 

Rate rise spurs student loan refinancing - Washington Times

  Rate Rise Spurs Student Loan Refinancing (Washington Times, 6/30/2006)
 

Public Citizens files Amicus Brief in support of OneSimpleLoan's DRA Court Challenge

  Actual Public Citizen Amicus Brief Filing in Support of OneSimpleLoan's Challenge of Deficit Reduction Act (9/6/2006)
 

Members of Congress file Amicus Brief in support of OneSimpleLoan's DRA Court Challenge

  Actual Amicus Brief Filing by Key Members of Congress in Support of OneSimpleLoan's Challenge of Deficit Reduction Act (9/8/2006)
 
     




OneSimpleLoan® Named 2007 Large Business of the Year

5/9/2007 - Oldsmar, FL - OneSimpleLoan® was named 2007 Large Business of the Year by the Upper Tampa Bay Regional Chamber of Commerce.
"We're big enough to serve you and small enough to care about you."
Apply for student loan consolidation by clicking here!
Apply for Student Loans